칼럼영국한국국제동포문화정보교양포토카페인터뷰촛점단신독자마당오늘의 운세기사제보
전체기사보기
한인주소록 벼룩시장 구인구직
편집  2017.12.11 [10:15]
동포 > 한인
필자의 다른기사 보기 인쇄하기 메일로 보내기 글자 크게 글자 작게
김인수씨 주간정보에 명예훼손 소송제기
재점화 된 '50여명 기러기 엄마 사기사건' 의 진실게임
 
런던타임즈 LONDONTIMES
 

▲   고등법원인  the high court of justice        © 런던타임즈 londontimes
 
재영한인들 사이에 명예훼손에 대한 소송이 발생했다. 

원고인 김인수씨와 그의 부인 김성혜씨가 동영수씨와 그의 부인 동융선씨 그리고 그들의 사업체인 메이스[mace (uk) ltd.]를 피고로 하여 출판물에 의한 명예훼손(defamation in libel) 소송을 제기한 것이다.

이번 소송에서 제3피고가 된 메이스는 격주로 발행되는 동포지 주간정보를 소유하고 있는 모 회사이며 제2피고는 주간정보의 편집인이다. 동영수씨는 메이스의 사장으로서 주간정보의 실질적인 발행인이라고 할 수 있다.

원고는 2008년 12월 10일 고등법원(the high court of justice)에 소송을 신청하였고 2009년 3월 27일 피고에게 소송장(particulars of claim)을 송달하였고 3월 31일 송달확인증(certificate of service)을 법원에 제출하였다. 

따라서 피고는 3월 31일로부터 14일 이내에 소송에 대해 대응을 해야 하며 이기간이 지나면 원고는 법원에 재판시작을 요청할 수 있게 된다

이번 소송은 그 동안 원고 김인수씨가 주간정보에 실린 명예훼손의 자료를 지난 1년 6개월 동안 수집하고 준비한 소송이라고 한다.

이 사건은 한국의 mbc가 2007년 4월 4일자 뉴스데스크와 4월 27일자 뉴스투데이를 통해 보도하여 한국과 영국의 한인사회에 파문과 함께 충격을 주었던 소위 ‘50여명 기러기 엄마 사기사건’에서부터 시발되었다.

mbc의 보도로 인해 사기사건의 당사자로 추정 지목되어 명예가 실추되며 사기꾼으로 몰리고 개인파산에 이르렀던 김인수씨는 급기야 2008년 mbc를 상대로 허위보도에 대해 소송을 제기하였다. 

2008년 6월의 1심 판결에서 mbc가 패소하고 원고에 대한 손해배상 및 ‘정정보도문’ 게재할 것을 명령 받았다(런던타임즈 2008년 6월 17일자 기사 참조). 그러나 mbc는 이에 불복하고 항소하였고 2009년 4월 15일에 2심 판결이 있을 예정이다.

주간정보는 mbc의 보도를 인용 게재하면서 김인수씨가 영국에 거주하는 서울대동문들에게 무고함을 호소하는 메일을 입수하여 공개 하는 등 mbc가 언급했던 김씨가 김인수라는 소문을 퍼트림으로써 원고의 명예를 훼손하였다는 것이 원고측 소송제기의 이유이다.  

동영수씨가 영국의 사기 고발센터인 nbfh (the national benefit fraud hotline)와 킹스톤 경찰서의 범죄 수사부(kingston police crime investigation unit)에 mbc의 보도를 인용하며 김인수씨가 자금세탁 등에 관련되어있다고 보고하였고 그 이후 지속적으로 주간정보를 통해 김인수씨의 실명과 함께 사기꾼, 악 등으로 묘사하며 명예를 훼손했다는 것이 원고측 클레임의 주 내용이다.

이에 더해 피고는 김인수씨의 주민등록번호를 주간정보에 공개함으로써 악용될 가능성으로 원고에게 피해를 입혔다는 사실도 클레임 내용에 포함되어 있다. 

‘50여명 기러기 엄마 사기사건’ 이라는 mbc의 보도는 한국법정의 1심에서 대부분 확인되지 않은 부정확한 허위사실에 근거했다는 지적을 받은바 있다. 또한 mbc 조차 법정에서 언급했던 김씨가 김인수씨가 아니라고 진술했다.

그러나 동영수씨 등은 이 사건이 사실인양 인용 보도하면서 자신을 범인으로 몰고 갔고 결국에는 파산하게 되어 명예와 신용 그리고 재산 등 모든 것을 잃었기에 소송을 제기할 수 밖에 없었다는 것이 원고측의 입장이다.

파산상태에서 막대한 소송비용을 감당할 수 없었던 김인수씨는 다행히 성공불 조건(no win no fee base)에 변호사를 선임할 수 있었다고 한다. 

성공불 조건에서 원고가 승소할 경우 피고가 원고측 변호사에게 지불해야 할 비용은 일반적인 비용의 최고 2배까지 올라가게 된다. 명예훼손 소송은 영국에서는 한국과 달리 민사소송에 속하지만 대개 고액의 변호사 비용이 소요되며 일반적인 사례를 보면 약 25만 파운드에 달한다. 

이번의 소송은 한국에서 진행되고 있는 원고와 mbc 간의 소송과도 연결되어 있어 국제적인 양상을 띄고 있다. 4월 15일로 예정된 한국의 2심 판결의 내용은 곧바로 영국법정에 참고자료로 제출될 예정이기 때문이다.   

‘런던타임즈’는 좀더 균형을 갖춘 사실의 파악과 반론을 듣기 위해 피고측에도 전화로 수 차례 접촉하였으나 취재를 거부하였기에 피고측의 입장을 반영할 수 없었지만 피고측이 반론을 제공해오면 공정하게 기사화할 예정이다.  
 
사기꾼이라는 주홍글씨를 가슴에 달고 쓰러졌던 김인수씨.

그가 골리앗 미디어들을 상대로 한국과 영국에서 벌인 소송들을 통해 인간승리를 이룰 것인지 무모하게 들고 나선 돌에 의해 자신의 이마에 낙인까지 추가할 것인지 과연 그 귀추가 주목된다.  


                                    < 런던타임즈 www.londontimes.tv >
 



 

기사입력: 2009/04/08 [13:23]  최종편집: ⓒ 런던타임즈
 
louis vuitton outlet california Leon Lai 14/08/06 [05:57] 수정 삭제
  louis vuitton outlet new york
louis vuitton outlets
http://www.cheap-louisvuittonoutlet.net?key=louis+vuitton+outlet+stores
http://www.cheap-louisvuittonoutlet.net
safe package deal is restricted to ABS as well as ESP, as well four safety bags.the particular mechanicals will most certainly be tried and tested, just somewhat on the ball. associated with forced the 301 along with Peugeot's 92bhp 1.6 diesel powered which has been sprightly more than enough, if not scintillatingly fairly fast. still obtained correctly exquisite. You will also gain biggest banking three storage container gas program yielding 72bhp, as well as a 115bhp 1.6 gasoline.typically the cycle caliber is undoubtedly bordering to do with mature center Peugeot, making it relaxed alongside merely takes a simple vague sign linked tone.
KRgFiZgjmC
Cheap Brazil World Cup 6s Nick 14/08/06 [06:54] 수정 삭제
  When he made the commercial advertisement for the other brands, people can still see this pair of shoes.. http://ntaolumvi.wikidot.com/cheap-jordan-carmine-6s-2014
http://www.bariatricsurgeryacademy.com/jordan-for-sale
http://www.pinterest.com/23Infrared11s/
http://www.bariatricsurgeryacademy.com/real-jordans-for-saleuYWvpgKGcg
cheap coach diaper bags Jaycee 14/08/06 [09:21] 수정 삭제
  Outside of all of your figures he probably died more than any other action figure in your collection. https://gitorious.org/+qanaoeel7
http://cheapcoachboutique.tumblr.com/cheap-coach
http://coachprice.tumblr.com/coach-purses-cheap-prices
http://coachprice.tumblr.com/coach-purses-cheap-pricesVItaCeBjiQ
a spot for beef 2nd annual holidays apparel special occasion Alien 14/08/09 [21:33] 수정 삭제
  christian louboutin for cheap http://www.cheap-christianlouboutin.com/christian-louboutin-for-cheap.html
cheap louboutin heels http://www.cheap-christianlouboutin.com/cheap-louboutin-heels.html
christian louboutin cheap http://www.cheap-christianlouboutin.com/christian-louboutin-cheap.html
cheap christian louboutin heels http://www.cheap-christianlouboutin.com/cheap-christian-louboutin-heels.html
cheap louboutins http://www.cheap-christianlouboutin.com/cheap-louboutins.html

Istanbul appointments

When I tell my friends that let me Istanbul, I am surprised to discover that nearly everyone I speak to has already been there. when they, also, Are surprised that I've never visited Turkey. So they offer me tips on what you'll do, the very best, How to bargain etc. Encouraged by this flood of knowledge, I change my bookings and extend my stay. If Istanbul is so tremendous, I want, Then I should enjoy it for extended.

I'm in Istanbul for a dinner to take off the Dom Prignon Ros 2002, So for my initial meal, My web host, Gaurav Bhatia because of Mot Chandon, Is kind enough to look at me to lunch. He picks a chic and elegant place called Vogue, On the top floor of an job site, With incredible views of the Bosphorus.

This is my first experience of Turkey and while Vogue's menu is online (several sushi, regarding), I ask for the Turkish motivated dishes. These develop into normal European dishes with slightly sweet dry fruit enriched sauces. Turks, I am to look for, Like fruit and that like a lot of sweetness in many of their dishes.

After snack, An English presenting guide takes me on a tour of the cheap louboutin shoes old city. Istanbul has a rich report. It is one of the world's oldest surviving cities, setting up as Byzantium, Becoming Constantinople and finally ending up as Istanbul. it was pretty, At one period, The world's single most important city and has always been regarded as the dividing line between East and West.

all of this, I examine, is very little idle boast. Geographers tell us that Asia and Europe are set aside by the Strait of Bosphorus. And Istanbul sprawls across each party of the Bosphorus. So you will find there's European part to the city and a quite distinct Asian part. it has an old city and there's a new city, Built around the 20th century. And you will discover an area that was once colonised by Venice and has quite distinctive Venetian architecture.

Few cities can change from place to place as completely as Istanbul does. The neighbourhood my hotel is situated in could be a part of Europe and as you go further down the road, in the evening Four Seasons, The watercraft, Waterside cafs, Hill villas and houses, Remind you of nothing almost southern Italy.

But in your existing city, with the crowded lanes and narrow alleys, The atmosphere is definitely Asian. locate beggars ("Gypsies, Spits my vehicle driver, Angrily), Street providers and carpet sellers. It is the design that I find most arresting. Istanbul's famous construction, like Blue Mosque, havin their six minarets, And Hagia Sophia are Islamic in player yet entirely unlike the mosques we see in India or the Arab world. This is a distinctly non Arab Islamic style, Heavily influenced by European engineering and by Christian traditions. (Hagia Sophia actually began as a church). I interact with Richard Geoffroy, The house's celebrated wine maker (I wrote about him some months ago in this particular column) And he promises that in the mail will be special.

principles in a bottle: Richard Geoffroy says that because Istanbul combines Eastern mystery with Western class, He thought it would be the right spot to launch the Ros which combines spices and the scent of roses in its bouquet

as well as it is. Dom has designed an all day extravaganza. We are put into small groups (I end up with the elegantly dressed Japanese Japan is Dom's second biggest market after America), And taken by boat around the Bosphorus to the old city. The first a section of the day is devoted to the Spice Market. cheap louboutin this ought to be to those of us brought up cheap christian louboutin on louboutin cheap tales of Middle Eastern bazaars a vast open space full of little stalls where old men sit behind mounds of spices while eating pistas from vast vats.

actually it is a covered market (Like Bombay's Crawford Market or Calcutta's New Market only much smaller) laden with shops, All of which sell exactly the same things: Saffron, Turkish treat, Caviar, Sherbet, Dry fruit and assorted household goods.

euro, Not spectacular: The Spice Market is unexpectedly clean and our guide complains that Europeans are often put off by how modern Istanbul can look

Three reasons for having the Spice Market are particularly striking. The first is that nearly half to two thirds of all the so-called goods on sale seem to come from Turkey's neighbour Iran: Saffron, Caviar, Pistas, for example. after the tourists stopped coming to Iran, That country's wares have been sent to Turkey and sold in Istanbul's markets. The second is that the Turks obviously think that many tourists suffer from male erectile dysfunction. Each shop provides "Turkish Viagra designed for Sultans" And the shopkeepers keep telling the japanese members of our party to try it: "Four times per night! Five times overnight, in which, After looking a fashionably dressed Japanese person along: "to aid you, May be only two times every hour,

The third is that because every shop sells the same principle, The shopkeepers have to do more. so they really beseech us as we pass, Shouting things they think will appeal: "your family Hindi! Shah Rukh Khan! Shah Rukh Khan, maybe "Salaam Aleikum asia or Pakistan,

The market is very clean and our guide complains that Europeans are often put off by how modern Istanbul can look. The manufacturers of Skyfall, the bond movie shot in Istanbul, states, Were so troubled by the real Spice Market that they built a set that looked more eastern exotic for Daniel Craig to run through.

Top ideas: Guerlain's Thierry Wasser has built new fragrances which reflect the smells of foods and spices such as clove, turmeric, Cardamom, Jasmine tea, Dried rose petals, and the like

Richard Geoffroy's intention is for us to uncover the smells, Spices and flavors of Istanbul, So we have been served Turkish snacks at Pandeli, A historic restaurant on the first floor of your market.

Then it is back on the boat and off to an art gallery where Dom Prignon has commandeered the in house restaurant. It is here that Thierry Wasser, The master perfumer from the grand old aroma house of Guerlain, complies with us. Thierry is fresh, fshionable, Articulate and lived in the US in the past. Since running over at Guerlain, He provides best selling new fragrances and tried to restore some of the house's tired old scents to their lost glory.

Today he wants us to understand romantic relationship between smell and taste, Between scented and food. He has created three new fragrances which reflect the smells of such foods and spices as clove, turmeric, Cardamom, Jasmine coffee, Dried rose petals, or anything else,.,and so. With each perfume, He makes us concoct our own mix of the

Ingredients whose smells most closely resemble it.

When he is through, He makes us combine all three scents. the combination gives us the scent of Ros Nacree du Desert, A fragrance he has built to match the Dom Prignon Ros 2002.

Our heads still reeling about smells of spice and rose, We take our boat to the Ciragan Palace Hotel where we will finally be allowed to taste the wine.

a section of the mythology of champagne is that it was invented by Dom Prignon, an actual monk who lived in France's Champagne region. this is probably nonsense but the association between Dom Prignon champagne and abbeys is a strong one. So Richard Geoffroy has had without needing using the balconies of the Ciragan Palace like church cloisters. Each of us is given a glass of the champagne and told to sit alone with the balconies overlooking the Bosphorus. We can take as long as we like to enjoy the wine and louboutin cheap stare at the sunlight glinting off the water.

so, I completely taste the 2002. I know it will good after all, 2002 was a great year for a bottle of wine; The normal 2002 Dom White has been generally praised so the Ros is bound to be special. But even I am surprised at the richness of the wine. It fills the mouth area and then as you swirl it around gently, it begins to reveal layer after layer of complexity.

Finally it is undoubtedly a technical tasting where Richard explains the wine. He says that because Istanbul combines Eastern mystery with Western complexity, He thought it would be the right place to launch the Ros which combines spices and the scent of roses in its bouquet. Hence the day's excursions and the collaboration with perfumer Thierry.

We head back to our hotel to improve for the formal launch dinner. Dom Prignon has taken over a medieval palace and converted it. in a tree floor, In the cocktail area, Waiters move with trays of canaps and bottles of champagne. I'm a little startled to know that the pre dinner champagne is the Oenothque 1993. Every few years or so, Richard raids the reserve wine stocks of Dom Prignon to issue a tiny the amount of an old vintage. These wines are called Oenothque and usually cost nearly double the as the normal Dom Prignon (and this, nonetheless, Is very costly). The claim is that the Oenothque range represents the talented champagne in the world so the massive price is worth it. but yet, Here it is only the circulation wine before the dinner! Does it make sense to overshadow a new vintage with such a great wine from the Oenothque range?

Dinner is on two long tables on the first floor of the palace. the light is blue and they project images of the Bosphorus onto our tables. The Ros 2002 is finally served when we can start, A shaven headed man in a flowing cloak who will be an Japanese journalist (Judging by the way members of our party dressed this morning) Or a Turkish dancer appears between the two dinner tables.

Then the music activity starts and the mystery is solved: he's a whirling dervish, setting aside time for before dinner is served. while it's true he whirls, I try your wine. wedding and reception stern and austere nature of the Oenothque Ros 1993, The Ros 2002 comes as a good change. Its round fullness colonises my mouth with its notes of citrus as well as apricots. I look to Richard, Who is sitting next to me and ask why on earth he served the Oenothque first. as it so happens, I choose the Ros 2002 but wasn't it a huge risk to serve such a great wine before dinner? "Yes definitely, He laughters. "But you must have balls, not,Which is as good an account of Richard's wine making style as any of us will ever come up with.

Whirls and home wine: A whirling dervish performs in gameplay before dinner is served on the first floor of a medieval palace.


CECGrRKTrK
cheap jordan shoes Alice 14/08/13 [04:11] 수정 삭제
  Violin, with Hartley name on it, is believed to have been found at sea with the musician body more than a week after the Titanic sank.. jordans for cheap http://avabundschuh.bravesites.com/entries/general/jordans-for-cheap
http://brazil6s.tumblr.com/brazil-world-cup-6s
https://code.google.com/p/jordan-shoes-for-sale/
http://brazil6s.tumblr.com/air-jordan-brazil-packMRiViPLvDQ
http://gardencuttings.org/y-2866 Cameron 14/08/17 [04:02] 수정 삭제
  http://learning-american-english.com/f-5249
http://www.kohalikule.ee/y-3048
http://www.abdiamondsdmcc.com/v-2490
http://www.restoreeyeserumfacts.com/z-8525
http://via101.com.br/w-6538
http://www.rvtlantiagingfacts.co.uk/n-9771
http://www.siyabasa.com/z-9226
http://fox72.com/y-6974
http://www.flashcopter.biz/p-2673
http://centros-estetica.enrubi.es/e-5508
http://www.localmetrix.com/n-8675
http://www.tonadermantiaging.com/p-1179
http://www.machineshoptech.com/d-6549
http://www.slimnojymfacts.com/x-3304
http://www.realmenhaterape.co.za/z-7349LInyIpNeKx
닉네임 패스워드 도배방지 숫자 입력
제목  
내용
기사 내용과 관련이 없는 글, 욕설을 사용하는 등 타인의 명예를 훼손하는 글은 관리자에 의해 예고 없이 임의 삭제될 수 있으므로 주의하시기 바랍니다.
 
뉴스

주간베스트
  회원약관기사제보보도자료기사검색
Londontimes.tv - published in Kingston/London, U.K. Namsantimes.com - published in Seoul, Korea 96-76 Itaewon-Dong, Yongsan-Gu, Seoul, Korea
Publisher : J Kim Tel : 020-8150-6562 (Korean No. 070-78478226 )
Copyright ⓒ 2007 런던타임즈. All rights reserved. email: londontimes.tv@hotmail.com